Landslide model evaluation
نویسندگان
چکیده
Introduction Conclusions References Tables Figures Back Close Full Screen / Esc Papers published in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences Discussions are under open-access review for the journal Hydrology and Earth System Sciences Abstract Introduction Conclusions References Tables Figures Back Close Full Screen / Esc Abstract The often-used success rate (SR) in measuring cell-based landslide model efficiency is based on the ratio of successfully predicted unstable cells over total actual landslide sites without considering the performance in predicting stable cells. We proposed a modified SR (MSR), in which we include the performance of stable cell prediction. The 5 goal and virtue of MSR is to avoid over-prediction while upholding stable sensitivity throughout all simulated cases. Landslide susceptibility maps (a total of 3969 cases) with full range of performance (from worse to perfect) in stable and unstable cell predictions are created and used to probe how estimators respond to model results in calculating efficiency. The kappa method used for satellite image analysis is drawn for 10 comparison. Results indicate that kappa is too stern for landslide modeling giving very low efficiency values in 90% simulated cases. The old SR tends to give high model efficiency under certain conditions yet with significant over-prediction. To examine the capability of MSR and the differences between SR and MSR as performance indicator, we applied the SHALSTAB model onto a mountainous watershed in Taiwan. Despite 15 the fact the best model result deduced by SR projects 120 hits over 131 actual landslide sites, this high efficiency is only obtained when unstable cells cover an incredibly high percentage (75%) of the entire watershed. By contrast, the best simulation indicated by MSR projects 83 hits over 131 actual landslide sites while unstable cells only cover 16% of the studied watershed.
منابع مشابه
Model of landslide hazard zonation and its effective factors using quantitative geomorphology (Case Study: Sanich region, Yazd)
Landslide can be considered as one of the important challenges of nature that affects natural areas and human societies. Several factors such as physical characteristics of the watershed, geology, soil structure, meteorology and hydrology are the most important environmental factors affecting in the landslide event. In order to reduce damage, landslide zoning have significant role in management...
متن کاملDeveloping a Model Based on Geospatial Information Systems (GIS) and Adaptive Neuro-Fuzzy Inference Systems (ANFIS) for Providing the Spatial Distribution Map of Landslide Risk. Case Study: Alborz Province
Landslide is one of these natural hazards which causes a great amount of financial and human damage annually allover the world. Accordingly, identification of areas with landslide threat for implementation of preventive measures in order to confront against the instability of hillsides for reduction of potential threats and related risks is very important. In this research a new method for clas...
متن کاملGIS-based landslide susceptibility mapping with probabilistic likelihood ratio and spatial multi-criteria evaluation models (north of Tehran, Iran)
The aim of this study is to produce landslide susceptibility mapping by probabilistic likelihood ratio (PLR) and spatial multi-criteria evaluation (SMCE) models based on geographic information system (GIS) in the north of Tehran metropolitan, Iran. The landslide locations in the study area were identified by interpretation of aerial photographs, satellite images, and field surveys. In order to ...
متن کاملLandslide Susceptibility Assessment Using Spatial Multi-Criteria Evaluation Model in Rwanda
Landslides susceptibility assessment has to be conducted to identify prone areas and guide risk management. Landslides in Rwanda are very deadly disasters. The current research aimed to conduct landslide susceptibility assessment by applying Spatial Multi-Criteria Evaluation Model with eight layers of causal factors including: slope, distance to roads, lithology, precipitation, soil texture, so...
متن کاملمقایسۀ نقشه های حساسیت زمین لغزش با استفاده از مدل رگرسیون لجستیک (LR) و مدل عمومی تجمیع یافته (GAM)
Landslide is one of the most common natural disasters that endanger the lives and properties of people in mountainous areas. Therefore, identification of risk exposure areas of landslide is essential to prevent and reduce damages by landslides. The purpose of this study is compared to logistic regression (LR) and generalized additive models (GAM) and the evaluation of their performance for land...
متن کاملارزیابی کارایی مدل احتمالاتی وزن واقعه در تهیه نقشه حساسیت زمین لغزش
Mass movements are usually natural erosion, but the human can aggravate it by operations such as mining, road construction and destroying the natural vegetation. The purpose of this study is to identify the factors influencing the occurrence of landslides by using a probabilistic model Weight of Evidence and Geography Information System in the Siyahbisheh Watershed. 132 landslide points are ide...
متن کامل